Convenient Morality: Public Opinion on Wartime Conduct | Nivedita Jhunjhunwala
Convenient Morality: Public Opinion on Wartime Conduct | Nivedita Jhunjhunwala
Tuesday, January 5, 202712:00 PM - 1:15 PM (Pacific)
William J. Perry Conference Room
About the event: Why do individuals respond differently to violations of international law during war time depending on who commits them? This paper argues that public judgments of wartime violations involve two distinct processes: condemnation of the violation and attribution of responsibility to the actor who committed it. While condemnation evaluates the act itself, responsibility attribution requires an additional judgment about the actor, creating greater scope for political favorability to shape accountability. Jhunjhunwala tests this argument using a factorial vignette survey experiment with 1,521 Indian respondents fielded between May and July 2026. Respondents evaluate wartime violations that vary in perpetrator identity, violation severity, and whether the conduct is explicitly framed as illegal under international law. She finds that favorability reduces both condemnation and responsibility attribution, but its effect on responsibility attribution is roughly twice as large. These findings reveal an accountability gap: individuals can recognize that conduct is wrong without holding a favored actor equally responsible for it. This distinction helps explain how international law norms can generate widespread condemnation while producing uneven judgments of accountability.
About the speaker: Nivedita Jhunjhunwala is a US-India Security Fellow at the Stanford Center for International Security and Cooperation (CISAC) and a Ph.D. Candidate in Government at the University of Texas at Austin, specializing in International Security, International Law, and Foreign Policy. Her research examines how global audiences perceive and react to international conflicts and violations of international law. She also studies state reputation and perceptions more generally in the context of the global "swing states", and the intersection of emerging technologies and politics.